Missionary Sisters of St. Charles Borromeo -- Scalabrinians Honduras
In Prayer Without Borders, Celebrating Global Wisdom, Barbara Ballenger, editor, Catholic Relief Services, 2004.
To have hope
Is to believe that history continues open
To the dream of God and to human creativity.
To have hope
Is to continue affirming
That it is possible to dream a different world,
Without hunger, without injustice,
Without discrimination.
To have hope
Is to be a courier of God
And a courier of men and women of good will,
Tearing down walls, destroying borders,
Building bridges.
To have hope
Is to believe in the revolutionary potential of faith,
Is to leave the door open so that
The Spirit can enter and make all things anew.
To have hope
Is to believe that life wins over deaths.
To have hope
Is to begin again as many times as necessary.
To have hope
Is to believe that hope is not
The last thing that dies.
To have hope
Is to believe that hope cannot die,
That hope no longer dies.
To have hope
Is to live.
Monday, August 31, 2009
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Reflections on a Summer in the Sonoran Desert, Part Seven
Peruvian liberation theologian Gustavo Gutierrez speaks at length about the importance of hope in the midst of human suffering. He says that “theology must remain committed to hope by having the capacity, freedom, and commitment to pay attention to the smallest of things… True theology must interpret the reasons for hope in whatever way possible.” So many of the people I have come to know and love who are doing this work are largely cynical people. It is so difficult not to be cynical caught in the middle of this tragedy, confronted daily with individuals whose experiences are unthinkable. Sometimes the phrase “saturated with suffering” runs through my head when I think about these borderlands. Sometimes I can’t find any hope. I don’t know if things will ever change. Sometimes it seems unlikely. Yet I imagine people saying the same thing about other overwhelming and systematic structures of power and injustice throughout history. Not that these things have disappeared, certainly, but the lives of many are better today because of very real social changes that have occurred. Apart from these questions of changing structures and systems of injustice, I find myself more and more pulled to the level of individual human interactions. I find hope in the fact that a man I came to know named Miguel refused to leave a woman in his group, Beatriz, alone when she fell down, even though they had never met before in their lives, and even though it meant that he risked death, alone and lost with her in the harshness of the desert. I find hope in the tears of my friends and fellow volunteers, in their willingness to suffer with others, to allow their hearts to be broken open with compassion. I find hope in my own tears and anger as they occur over and over again, never becoming easier, never reaching a level of desensitization to the pain of others, and the strength and courage this gives me to keep doing this work. I find hope in the act of love and sacrifice that migration is for so many men and women, the giving up of ones personal safety and comfort for the sustenance of others. In all of these things, and in many more, I find hope, and even though they are perhaps “the smallest of things,” together they make a mighty force of love and compassion and hope for another world that is, I believe, possible.
Reflections on a Summer in the Sonoran Desert, Part Six
The arbitrariness of the Borderlands is always with me. Earlier this summer, another volunteer and I walked out of the desert after a 15 mile hike, just in time to see two men walking on the side of the road ahead of us. Within a minute of our seeing them, a border patrol truck sped into view, pulled over, and had them out of the brush, on the side of the road, with both agents frisking them down and ultimately shoving them into the back of the vehicle. As we came into view, one of the agents began to walk towards us. The first words out of his mouth were, “Did you two need anything, or are you okay?” Little things like this have happened repeatedly while I’ve been out here, but they never cease to impact me. Did we need anything? Were we okay? We were not frisked and shoved into the back of a vehicle, without any concern for the fact that we had probably walked multiple days in near 100 degree heat, undoubtedly without sufficient water, probably without food for the past few days, most likely with incredibly painful blisters, aches, and cramping throughout our bodies. No one asks these people their stories as they shove them behind the locked doors. If they did, what would they hear? They would hear Ignacio, who worked in a factory for fourteen years of his life in Mexico, under terrible working conditions, never making enough to put enough food on the table. Ignacio brought a stack of tourist postcards from his home town of Puebla, and offered one to me with the graciousness of a prince, as we sat under a tree, miles from anything in the middle of the desert, and I asked him when the last time he had vomited from drinking the cow tank water was. Last night. They would hear Cruz, who had the worst blisters I have ever seen, cutting through multiple layers of skin, open and bleeding, say simply as I told him I was worried about the possibility of infection if he kept on walking, “But it doesn’t matter. I have to be with my family.” They would have to listen to Felipe, who was migrating in search of work to pay the doctor’s bills for his six year old daughter, born with neurological problems. I asked him his story and he began, “Pues, Dios nos mandó una hija…” (Well, God sent us a little girl…). They would have to look into the face of Armando, who thought he was dying until we happened to take a wrong turn on the road and come across him, explain between gasps and gulps of water, that everything was chingado in the town that he came from and all he wanted was work to earn money for his kids. Armando thought he was dying, and twenty minutes later a border patrol agent stood over him saying roughly “Puedes parar? Pues, parate!” (Can you stand up? Well, stand up, then!). They would have to sit down on the side of the road with Juan, who had a temperature of 105 when we came across each other, and wish that there was something, anything, they could say that would make a difference as he, a grown man, sobbed heartbrokenly, saying over and over “I’m a good person, all I want is to be with my children and take care of my mom who is sick.” What do you say to someone who is crying like that? When you know that their situation is hopeless? When you would give anything to be able to tell them that you would do whatever it took, that it would all be all right? But in your heart you know the reality of the situation. It is not all right. It probably will never be.
Blessed Are
Prayer by Fr. José Alfredo Goncalves, Brazil
From Prayer Without Borders: Celebrating Global Wisdom, Catholic Relief Services: Baltimore, MD, 2004.
Blessed are those who are on the move,
transforming exodus and flight in energy for a new search.
From the victims will come the protagonists of history.
Blessed are those who, forced to wander without direction,
with wisdom learn and teach the lessons of the road.
They will be the architects of a new time.
Blessed are those who suffer pain, nostalgia and loneliness,
yet know how to make of every arrival a new beginning.
They shall act with faith, hope and life.
Blessed are those who open borders
and mix the anthems, flags, races and creeds.
Without discrimination, they make the world everyone’s home.
Blessed are the wayfarers of all roads
in the tears, sweat and the work of their hands.
They prepare a tomorrow of justice and right.
Blessed are those who open the doors to pilgrims,
making solidarity the passport to our common homeland.
They are constructing a new citizenship.
Blessed are those who foment encounters and re-encounters, sowing peace,
They will harvest flowers and stars in the new heaven and the new earth.
Blessed are the excluded, without opportunities and without voice.
They will be the first guests in the great banquet,
where bread will not be lacking on anyone’s table.
From Prayer Without Borders: Celebrating Global Wisdom, Catholic Relief Services: Baltimore, MD, 2004.
Blessed are those who are on the move,
transforming exodus and flight in energy for a new search.
From the victims will come the protagonists of history.
Blessed are those who, forced to wander without direction,
with wisdom learn and teach the lessons of the road.
They will be the architects of a new time.
Blessed are those who suffer pain, nostalgia and loneliness,
yet know how to make of every arrival a new beginning.
They shall act with faith, hope and life.
Blessed are those who open borders
and mix the anthems, flags, races and creeds.
Without discrimination, they make the world everyone’s home.
Blessed are the wayfarers of all roads
in the tears, sweat and the work of their hands.
They prepare a tomorrow of justice and right.
Blessed are those who open the doors to pilgrims,
making solidarity the passport to our common homeland.
They are constructing a new citizenship.
Blessed are those who foment encounters and re-encounters, sowing peace,
They will harvest flowers and stars in the new heaven and the new earth.
Blessed are the excluded, without opportunities and without voice.
They will be the first guests in the great banquet,
where bread will not be lacking on anyone’s table.
Reflections on a Summer in the Sonoran Desert, Part Five
In my experience, the world of academia can very easily come to see itself as an end in itself. I have friends and colleagues who will happily debate an esoteric question for hours, finding joy in the purely intellectual realm of the conversation. I walk the aisles of the library and shake my head in wonder that someone cared enough to write hundreds of pages about topics that are so seemingly irrelevant. I hesitate to condemn absolutely, because I understand the thirst for knowledge and the joy of learning, testing, challenging, and debating. But when I sit by the side of the road with someone like Martín, when I listen to the sorrow in the voice of someone like Rubén, or share in the indignation at human injustice with someone like Jesus, I cannot find much value in dedicating one’s life to words and thoughts, but never actions. I find a tremendous challenge in the words of Ghandi: “Whenever you are in doubt… apply the following test. Recall the fact of the poorest and weakest man you may have seen, and ask yourself if the step you contemplate is going to be any use to him.” This is a radical prioritization; it is mirrored in the preferential option for the poor that is spoken of by liberation theology. Perhaps when the world we live in is a more just one there will be a place for dedicating resources to knowledge as nothing more than an end in itself. Until then, there is a very legitimate critique of the inefficacy of systems of higher education that do not use knowledge as a tool for social change to benefit those who are oppressed and marginalized.
Some of the people I am most inspired by are those who are led by their hearts, and are committed to bringing about a better world that they believe to be possible, but whose work is also informed by an intellectual analysis that comes directly from this commitment and vision of the world as they want it to be. This combination, which is all too rare, is what I struggle to find in my own life and work. I hope that my experiences providing humanitarian aid in the desert along the U.S.-Mexico border, coupled with the opportunities I have had to explore deeper structural questions at an intellectual level, will lead me to action that is thoughtful and effective. Being at the border, along with finishing a graduate education, has taught me that there are no easy answers. How to remain committed to the individuals whose stories I have come to know in the desert, but to see things in the broader sense, to work to change policies and to shape the future of a world that will be more just, more humane? After two years of graduate school and three summers at the border, I know beyond a doubt that I will grapple with these questions for the rest of my life.
Some of the people I am most inspired by are those who are led by their hearts, and are committed to bringing about a better world that they believe to be possible, but whose work is also informed by an intellectual analysis that comes directly from this commitment and vision of the world as they want it to be. This combination, which is all too rare, is what I struggle to find in my own life and work. I hope that my experiences providing humanitarian aid in the desert along the U.S.-Mexico border, coupled with the opportunities I have had to explore deeper structural questions at an intellectual level, will lead me to action that is thoughtful and effective. Being at the border, along with finishing a graduate education, has taught me that there are no easy answers. How to remain committed to the individuals whose stories I have come to know in the desert, but to see things in the broader sense, to work to change policies and to shape the future of a world that will be more just, more humane? After two years of graduate school and three summers at the border, I know beyond a doubt that I will grapple with these questions for the rest of my life.
Reflections on a Summer in the Sonoran Desert, Part Four
- Article 8: Everyone has the right to an effective remedy by the competent national tribunals for acts violating the fundamental rights granted him by the constitution or by law.
One of the most difficult situations I find myself in is sitting with a grown man who is crying. When I am with a woman there is usually a different connection, I can cry with her, hold her, relate in a deeper way. For some reason, this is more complicated with a man. I remember sitting with Luís, who was just a few years older than myself, as tears ran down his face and he repeated “La vida es dura. Tan dura” (Life is hard. So hard). He rested for a night, then continued walking north. A few hours later he found his way back to our camp after having been robbed of everything we had given him – food, water, a backpack – by bandits a few miles away.
Impunity is commonplace along the migrant trail. Many of the people I talk to have been robbed at gunpoint at some point of their journey, whether in México before crossing, right at the border, or somewhere in the remoteness of the desert, where no one is there to care. What recourse does a person without money or connections, let alone documentation authorizing her to be in this country, have?
One of the most difficult situations I find myself in is sitting with a grown man who is crying. When I am with a woman there is usually a different connection, I can cry with her, hold her, relate in a deeper way. For some reason, this is more complicated with a man. I remember sitting with Luís, who was just a few years older than myself, as tears ran down his face and he repeated “La vida es dura. Tan dura” (Life is hard. So hard). He rested for a night, then continued walking north. A few hours later he found his way back to our camp after having been robbed of everything we had given him – food, water, a backpack – by bandits a few miles away.
Impunity is commonplace along the migrant trail. Many of the people I talk to have been robbed at gunpoint at some point of their journey, whether in México before crossing, right at the border, or somewhere in the remoteness of the desert, where no one is there to care. What recourse does a person without money or connections, let alone documentation authorizing her to be in this country, have?
- Article 23: Everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment.
“Chiapas es hermosa, pero no hay dinero.” Chiapas is beautiful, but there is no money. Or work. I sat with Jesus, a father of two small children from Southern México, and listened to the words I have heard so many times. Because of the lack of employment in his home community, Jesus, along with his wife Sara, decided to make the journey north with their two small children. When I met their family they were all in fairly bad shape. Sara had terrible blisters on her feet, making it all but impossible for her to walk. Their four-year-old son had drunk the cow tank water and spent a morning vomiting in our camp, his tiny body limp with misery. I wonder what would have happened to them if we hadn’t come across each other that morning. When I reflect on the tremendous cost the journey had for this family, I find it difficult to imagine that they would have chosen to undertake it if there was a way that they could have sustained themselves in Chiapas.
- Article 25: (1) Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.
How many would migrate if these conditions were all met in their home countries? Who is responsible for the fact that they are so overwhelmingly not?
Monday, August 17, 2009
Reflections on a Summer in the Sonoran Desert, Part Three

In the Human Rights in Latin America seminar I took last year, we spent a great deal of time discussing the formulation of universal human rights standards. There are so many rights that have been recognized and established by the international community, and that sound so beautiful. I don’t mean to sound cynical, because I do believe that progress has been made over the last century towards establishing an increasingly respected system of universal rights that provides at least a starting place for dialogue and action. But like so many good things at the international level (labor and environmental side agreements to free trade accords, for example!), in practice they are often little more than words on paper. I could write a litany of the human rights violations I witness and am told of daily in the desert. So many people migrate because their basic human needs are not met within their home countries. And so many meet with such injustice during their journeys, injustice which, tragically, does not end in the desert, but continues all over the country. It is strange to read the text of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and imagine a world in which every human being was not just entitled to but actually lived with all of the rights listed there…
- Article 3: Everyone has the right to life, liberty, and security of person.
My friend Dan was walking in a remote canyon last February when he came across the body of a little girl. Josseline was a 14-year-old from El Salvador who had been traveling with her 10-year-old brother to reunite with their mother in Los Angeles. She became sick during the journey and was left behind by her group. She had wandered for about a week before carefully taking off her shoes, lying down on the canyon floor, and falling asleep. Her cause of death was listed as exposure. Josseline was two months younger than my little sister, and I see her when I look at Laura and wonder what her life would have been like in Los Angeles with the mother she hadn’t seen in so long.
In an essay entitled “The Value of Immigrant Life,” Jonathan Xavier Inda uses Foucault’s concept of “biopower” (the power over life exercised by the state) to describe the way policy pertaining to “illegal” immigration is rationalized. He says that there is a distinction made by the state between those lives that are part of the social body and those that are to be excluded; the former are prioritized, while the latter are expendable. This does not necessarily mean that there is the intent that migrants should die, but that “in order to protect its population, the Border Patrol, and the federal government more generally, is willing to tolerate a few casualties." The state is thus engaged in “distinguishing between those lives that deserve to be lived and those that can be disallowed to the point of death.” While I am sure that no one desired her death, Josseline’s life was seen as expendable, just one of the “few casualties” that are acceptable in the name of “securing the border.” Josseline died because of policies that are in place to purportedly protect U.S. citizens. Like my little sister Laura. The irony of this overwhelms me.
- Article 3: Everyone has the right to life, liberty, and security of person.
My friend Dan was walking in a remote canyon last February when he came across the body of a little girl. Josseline was a 14-year-old from El Salvador who had been traveling with her 10-year-old brother to reunite with their mother in Los Angeles. She became sick during the journey and was left behind by her group. She had wandered for about a week before carefully taking off her shoes, lying down on the canyon floor, and falling asleep. Her cause of death was listed as exposure. Josseline was two months younger than my little sister, and I see her when I look at Laura and wonder what her life would have been like in Los Angeles with the mother she hadn’t seen in so long.
In an essay entitled “The Value of Immigrant Life,” Jonathan Xavier Inda uses Foucault’s concept of “biopower” (the power over life exercised by the state) to describe the way policy pertaining to “illegal” immigration is rationalized. He says that there is a distinction made by the state between those lives that are part of the social body and those that are to be excluded; the former are prioritized, while the latter are expendable. This does not necessarily mean that there is the intent that migrants should die, but that “in order to protect its population, the Border Patrol, and the federal government more generally, is willing to tolerate a few casualties." The state is thus engaged in “distinguishing between those lives that deserve to be lived and those that can be disallowed to the point of death.” While I am sure that no one desired her death, Josseline’s life was seen as expendable, just one of the “few casualties” that are acceptable in the name of “securing the border.” Josseline died because of policies that are in place to purportedly protect U.S. citizens. Like my little sister Laura. The irony of this overwhelms me.
Reflections on a Summer in the Sonoran Desert, Part Two
In July of 2007, just before beginning a graduate program at American University, I came to the desert for the first time. I had spent a year living in a house of hospitality for those who had recently crossed the border in Texas, and had seen the exhaustion on the faces of the men, women, and children who knocked on our door seeking food, a place to rest, sometimes medical care, after having just made it across. Every week in the house we had a community celebration and mass of thanksgiving for the safe arrival of those who had come during the previous days. Each week, one person shared their testimonio, the story of their journey across the line into the U.S. I wanted to better understand that journey that I had heard described in such compelling, often heart-wrenching words. I wanted to be a part of trying to eliminate the death and the intense suffering that were a part of the equation for so many. I spent two weeks in the desert that summer before leaving to start classes. The next summer I came back for ten weeks. My life changed during that time. Everything seemed simpler, starker. The priorities of the rest of the world were backwards. All that really mattered was water. And a heart full of love, a heart that was resilient and could be broken open time and time again. A heart capable of tremendous compassion, in the sense of “suffering with” others. I came to see how upside-down the world in general was and the reality of the border in particular. I contemplated dropping out of school, giving up everything to stay and do this work. I ultimately decided not break these commitments, but to take a year, with the promise that I would return as soon as possible. That ended up being May of this year and this is how I came to be sitting on an isolated dirt road with Martín that day.
I try to remember the lessons I have learned over the past few years as both a graduate student and a humanitarian aid worker, a scholar and an activist, the times I have had a moment of realization or a deepening of understanding that has really altered my way of seeing things. I try to make the connections between the human encounters I have had at the border and the broader questions I have grappled with in an academic context. Sometimes the correlations are clear, sometimes they are not. At times I feel that I am nothing more than the keeper of this enormous repository of stories…
So many names, so many faces… Efren and his sister Elvia, who was so scared and so grateful to find herself with other women; Ignacio with the postcards from Puebla and Cruz who believed his open and bloody feet were a punishment from God for causing his family to suffer; Benjamin from Oaxaca; Felipe who was walking all the way to Tucson and had trouble keeping his eyes open for exhaustion; Edgar who picked lemons in California; Cristína and Jorge who were soñando de agua pura (dreaming of clean water) and who vomited when they finally drank our water; Jesús and Cruz who played soccer with us; Ignacio with the sprained – perhaps broken – ankle, who kept walking; Felipe with the six-year-old daughter with neurological problems que Dios les mandó (that God had sent them) and Vicente who made us laugh; Rubén who never smiled and who would have given up days before if it weren’t for his sick mother waiting for him; Juan who sobbed as I sat with him and whose body temperature after several days of walking was 105 degrees; Juan Carlos and Javier who were just boys; Elva who was the sole woman in a group of ten men; Gemmy who we promised medical attention to as he lay prone on the desert floor, his face contorted with pain, and who was deported hours later; Felipe who was medically evacuated and Pedro who he didn’t want to be separated from (when I close my eyes, I can still see little Pedro sitting all alone after they had taken Felipe away, surrounded by people in uniforms, so far from Oaxaca); Francisco whose entire body hurt; the other Francisco with the pale face and the huge eyes who had been vomiting; the five men whose names I can’t remember who woke me up at midnight and wanted coffee; Nelson who walked out of our camp singing; Cruz who gave his shoes away to a kid he met on the trail with a sprained ankle; Lucy who was unconscious when we found her; Aurora and the little girls, 4 and 7 years old, who just wanted to draw pictures, cook Top Ramen on the camp stove, and go on frog hunts; Sara who carried her two year old daughter over two mountain ranges while wearing flip-flops; little Cristian, age 4, who walked for two days all by himself and whose face was cut and scratched from the branches along the way … How can I remember each of them forever, with their unique stories and their own individual hopes and terrors. I don’t even know where any of them are right now. Which of them would not be walking the earth at this moment if it were not for our presence in the desert? Is it even worth thinking about? Hacemos lo que hacemos, ya basta (We do what we do, that's enough).
I try to remember the lessons I have learned over the past few years as both a graduate student and a humanitarian aid worker, a scholar and an activist, the times I have had a moment of realization or a deepening of understanding that has really altered my way of seeing things. I try to make the connections between the human encounters I have had at the border and the broader questions I have grappled with in an academic context. Sometimes the correlations are clear, sometimes they are not. At times I feel that I am nothing more than the keeper of this enormous repository of stories…
So many names, so many faces… Efren and his sister Elvia, who was so scared and so grateful to find herself with other women; Ignacio with the postcards from Puebla and Cruz who believed his open and bloody feet were a punishment from God for causing his family to suffer; Benjamin from Oaxaca; Felipe who was walking all the way to Tucson and had trouble keeping his eyes open for exhaustion; Edgar who picked lemons in California; Cristína and Jorge who were soñando de agua pura (dreaming of clean water) and who vomited when they finally drank our water; Jesús and Cruz who played soccer with us; Ignacio with the sprained – perhaps broken – ankle, who kept walking; Felipe with the six-year-old daughter with neurological problems que Dios les mandó (that God had sent them) and Vicente who made us laugh; Rubén who never smiled and who would have given up days before if it weren’t for his sick mother waiting for him; Juan who sobbed as I sat with him and whose body temperature after several days of walking was 105 degrees; Juan Carlos and Javier who were just boys; Elva who was the sole woman in a group of ten men; Gemmy who we promised medical attention to as he lay prone on the desert floor, his face contorted with pain, and who was deported hours later; Felipe who was medically evacuated and Pedro who he didn’t want to be separated from (when I close my eyes, I can still see little Pedro sitting all alone after they had taken Felipe away, surrounded by people in uniforms, so far from Oaxaca); Francisco whose entire body hurt; the other Francisco with the pale face and the huge eyes who had been vomiting; the five men whose names I can’t remember who woke me up at midnight and wanted coffee; Nelson who walked out of our camp singing; Cruz who gave his shoes away to a kid he met on the trail with a sprained ankle; Lucy who was unconscious when we found her; Aurora and the little girls, 4 and 7 years old, who just wanted to draw pictures, cook Top Ramen on the camp stove, and go on frog hunts; Sara who carried her two year old daughter over two mountain ranges while wearing flip-flops; little Cristian, age 4, who walked for two days all by himself and whose face was cut and scratched from the branches along the way … How can I remember each of them forever, with their unique stories and their own individual hopes and terrors. I don’t even know where any of them are right now. Which of them would not be walking the earth at this moment if it were not for our presence in the desert? Is it even worth thinking about? Hacemos lo que hacemos, ya basta (We do what we do, that's enough).
Reflections on a Summer in the Sonoran Desert
It was already late afternoon, but the sun beat down no less intensely on the stretch of dirt road where I sat, about nine miles north of the U.S.-Mexico border in the Sonoran desert. There was no shade in sight, the largest objects around inhospitable mesquite and cactus. This day I was sitting cross-legged with a middle-aged man from Chiapas named Martín. Martín had crossed the border two days before and had been walking almost nonstop ever since. He had awakened the night before to find that his guía, along with the rest of the group that he was walking with, were gone. This is not an uncommon occurrence; those who are too slow due to age, lack of physical fitness, or injury are frequently left behind. Miles from anything and without knowledge of the harsh geographical terrain, the probability of not making it through is much too high. While the resourcefulness of those who are making this crossing should not be discounted, the number of bodies recovered along the border since the mid-1990s averages around one each day. These are, of course, only the bodies that are found; given the remoteness and inaccessibility of the region, it is certainly accurate to assume that many more are never discovered.
Unlike most of the people I meet in this area, Martín still had some food and clean water with him. Also unlike many, he had not drunk from the small watering holes that are virtually the only source of water in the region. Contaminated by the cattle that roam freely in this part of the country, consumption of this water causes many to become desperately sick in a short period of time. While fortunate in that his physical state was good, apart from total exhaustion after two days of walking in extreme temperatures, he was not fortunate in that he was still at least two more days walk from the closest reasonable destination, the interstate. With no other real options available to him, Martín asked for Border Patrol to be called, so that he could be returned to México.
As we sat by the side of the road waiting for the truck to arrive, we shared water, some fruit, and our stories. Martín’s was similar to countless others I have listened to in the desert. He had two small children back home. Times were so difficult in México with la crisis, it was harder than ever to make ends meet. The prices of basic staples – beans, tortillas – kept going up, not just once or twice, but over and over. Also his mom, who was living in California, was pretty sick and he didn’t think she would be able to hold on for much longer. She had diabetes and was going downhill quickly. Or that’s what they told him, he hadn’t seen her in a long while. He just wanted to be with her, and to be able to make some money to send home to his wife and kids. That was pretty much it. My story was pretty straightforward, as well. I happened to end up on the same dirt road as Martín that day because I work with a group called No Más Muertes or No More Deaths, whose mission is to end death and suffering through the provision of humanitarian aid in the desert along the U.S.-Mexico border. We had just finished leaving over a hundred gallons of water at various places along well-traveled migrant trails in the area. Martín said that we did good and much-needed work, and he was very grateful to have encountered us. We heard the crunch of gravel on the road in the distance and we started to say our goodbyes. The truck pulled up and an armed and uniformed agent loaded Martín into the back and without wasting any time, turned and drove back out the road.
Juan Villoro says that the border is “an enormous repository of stories.” When I reflect on my time in the Sonoran desert along the U.S.-Mexico border, a thousand stories, along with the faces that correspond with those stories, course through my thoughts. I think back to the hours I spent in seminars in Washington, DC, writing endless papers, reading even more endless stacks of books and articles. I try to integrate those faces with the hours I spent reading, writing, and talking about concepts and ideas… dependency theory, sustainable development, immigration policy, neoliberalism. Cruz, Elizabet, Felipe, Ángel, Daniel, Shirley, Aurora, Cynthia, Vanessa, Francisco, Jorge, Lucy, Estela… I ask myself if anything that I learned in two years of graduate school helps me to understand this situation in a more profound way or to do this work more effectively. I still struggle with this question.
Unlike most of the people I meet in this area, Martín still had some food and clean water with him. Also unlike many, he had not drunk from the small watering holes that are virtually the only source of water in the region. Contaminated by the cattle that roam freely in this part of the country, consumption of this water causes many to become desperately sick in a short period of time. While fortunate in that his physical state was good, apart from total exhaustion after two days of walking in extreme temperatures, he was not fortunate in that he was still at least two more days walk from the closest reasonable destination, the interstate. With no other real options available to him, Martín asked for Border Patrol to be called, so that he could be returned to México.
As we sat by the side of the road waiting for the truck to arrive, we shared water, some fruit, and our stories. Martín’s was similar to countless others I have listened to in the desert. He had two small children back home. Times were so difficult in México with la crisis, it was harder than ever to make ends meet. The prices of basic staples – beans, tortillas – kept going up, not just once or twice, but over and over. Also his mom, who was living in California, was pretty sick and he didn’t think she would be able to hold on for much longer. She had diabetes and was going downhill quickly. Or that’s what they told him, he hadn’t seen her in a long while. He just wanted to be with her, and to be able to make some money to send home to his wife and kids. That was pretty much it. My story was pretty straightforward, as well. I happened to end up on the same dirt road as Martín that day because I work with a group called No Más Muertes or No More Deaths, whose mission is to end death and suffering through the provision of humanitarian aid in the desert along the U.S.-Mexico border. We had just finished leaving over a hundred gallons of water at various places along well-traveled migrant trails in the area. Martín said that we did good and much-needed work, and he was very grateful to have encountered us. We heard the crunch of gravel on the road in the distance and we started to say our goodbyes. The truck pulled up and an armed and uniformed agent loaded Martín into the back and without wasting any time, turned and drove back out the road.
Juan Villoro says that the border is “an enormous repository of stories.” When I reflect on my time in the Sonoran desert along the U.S.-Mexico border, a thousand stories, along with the faces that correspond with those stories, course through my thoughts. I think back to the hours I spent in seminars in Washington, DC, writing endless papers, reading even more endless stacks of books and articles. I try to integrate those faces with the hours I spent reading, writing, and talking about concepts and ideas… dependency theory, sustainable development, immigration policy, neoliberalism. Cruz, Elizabet, Felipe, Ángel, Daniel, Shirley, Aurora, Cynthia, Vanessa, Francisco, Jorge, Lucy, Estela… I ask myself if anything that I learned in two years of graduate school helps me to understand this situation in a more profound way or to do this work more effectively. I still struggle with this question.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
